Imagine standing at a cash register for eight hours, day after day, without a single chance to sit. Or clocking in and realizing you won’t be paid for the last hour you worked. For decades, corporations treated these issues as minor complaints. But California workers fought back — and won millions. This blog covers the landmark seating and wage-hour cases that reshaped workplace rights. From CVS’s Supreme Court showdown to Walmart’s $65 million bombshell, these are stories of dignity, health, and the law. Case 1: Kilby v. CVS (2016 Supreme Court Decision) CVS cashiers and customer reps stocked shelves, bagged groceries, cleaned counters — and rang up sales. Most tasks could have been done sitting. But CVS forbade it. The California Supreme Court ruled in 2016 that employers must examine each specific task: If a job reasonably permits sitting, seats must be provided. Employers cannot argue “the overall job requires standing” as an excuse. This case set the legal foundation for every settlement that followed. Case 2: Bank of America – $15 Million Settlement Tellers across California stood behind counters, even when processing paperwork or waiting on customers. The work could be done seated, but chairs were denied. After years of litigation, Bank of America paid $15 million. Three named plaintiffs received $25,000 each. Workers collectively received millions in payouts. BofA had to implement a new seating policy and inform employees of their rights. As one teller put it: “We weren’t asking for luxury. We just wanted chairs.” Case 3: Safeway – $12 Million Settlement Cashier Eva Sharp led a class action spanning nearly eight years. She and thousands of Safeway cashiers stood long shifts without stools, despite registers allowing seating. The 2019 settlement totaled $12 million: Eva received ~$14,000. 30,000+ cashiers split about $1.8 million. Safeway promised to supply seating for two years. It was a small fortune for many minimum-wage workers — and proof persistence pays off. Case 4: Target – $9 Million Settlement Target’s bright red stores carried a dark reality: over 90,000 cashiers in California were denied seating. The company agreed to pay $9 million, with roughly $3.9 million in attorney fees. Though workers’ individual payouts were modest, the scale was enormous — showing how widespread the issue was. Case 5: Walmart – $65 Million Bombshell The largest seating case ever. Nearly 100,000 Walmart cashiers joined forces after years of standing at registers. Walmart agreed to pay $65 million in 2018. Individual payouts reached $25,000 per worker. Walmart changed practices nationwide. It wasn’t just a California win. It set off a national conversation: do workers deserve dignity at the register? The answer was clear. Case 6: AutoZone (Meda v. AutoZone, 2022) AutoZone claimed it “provided seats.” In reality, two chairs were tucked away in management areas, far from the registers. Workers didn’t even know they could sit. The court ruled that “mere availability” isn’t enough. Seats must be accessible at the workstation. Workers must be informed they’re allowed to sit. This case clarified that employers can’t just check a box — they must genuinely make seating available. Case 7: Ralphs (LaFace v. Ralphs, 2022) In a rare loss for workers, Ralphs argued its cashiers never had downtime. Courts agreed, ruling that constant customer flow meant no obligation to provide seating. The case also confirmed that PAGA seating claims are bench trials (decided by judges, not juries). This showed the law isn’t automatic — context matters. Broader Impact These cases changed more than policy. They changed lives: Health: Less back pain, fewer leg injuries. Dignity: Workers finally treated like humans, not props. Financial Relief: Payouts gave families breathing room. And beyond California, they inspired other states and employers to review seating rules voluntarily. Conclusion From CVS to Walmart, workers proved one truth: when they stand together, they win the right to sit. At WRCA, we fight to keep this momentum going. 👉 Join WRCA today. Subscribe, share, and support workers’ rights.
Tag: Workers Rights Compliance Alliance
Fired for mistakenly eating the wrong Lunch
Fired for Eating the Wrong Lunch: A Wake-Up Call for Workers Everywhere
After more than two decades of loyal service, Israel Xicohtencatl, a dedicated produce manager at the iconic Citarella Gourmet Market in New York City, was suddenly and publicly fired. His offense? He accidentally ate a coworker’s lunch.
Yes, you read that right. A minor mistake—one that could happen to any of us—ended Israel’s 20+ year career.
A Loyal Worker, Tossed Aside
On May 28, 2025, Israel unknowingly grabbed a bagged lunch that wasn’t his. As soon as he realized the error, he apologized, tried to make it right, and offered to buy a replacement. But instead of understanding, Citarella’s head of security fired him on the spot.
The next day, the company made it official with a termination letter.
Now, Israel is fighting back—with a lawsuit under the New York State and City Human Rights Laws, accusing Citarella of age discrimination and targeting long-time employees to cut costs.
Humiliated, Depressed, and Blacklisted
Israel’s termination wasn’t just a job loss—it shattered his dignity.
“I’ve experienced profound shame and embarrassment,” he says in his complaint. “Coworkers saw it happen. Word spread. My professional reputation is ruined.”
Since his firing, Israel has been unable to find a new job. Employers repeatedly ask why he left Citarella, forcing him to relive the humiliation over and over again. He can’t even use the company as a reference.
Worse, his emotional health has plummeted. Anxiety. Depression. Insomnia. Years of purpose and routine gone—because of a lunch.
A Pattern of Discrimination
This wasn’t an isolated incident. Israel says other longtime employees were also let go for similarly petty reasons—one for drinking a coworker’s soda. The lawsuit alleges Citarella is systematically pushing out older, higher-paid workers and replacing them with cheaper, younger staff.
That’s not just unfair—it’s illegal.
What This Means for You
If it can happen to Israel, it can happen to anyone.
Loyalty no longer protects workers. Fairness isn’t guaranteed. And justice rarely comes without a fight.
That’s why we founded the Workers Rights Compliance Alliance (WRCA)—to stand up for people like Israel, and for you.
We expose these abuses.
We connect wronged workers with legal support.
We fight for better labor standards across the country.
✊ Join the Movement. Defend Your Rights.
If you’ve been fired unfairly, misclassified, denied wages, or treated unjustly in the workplace—you’re not alone.
➡️ Join WRCA today—100% free.
➡️ Tell us your story.
➡️ Help us protect workers like Israel—before it happens to someone else.
👉 Visit: WorkersRightsComplianceAlliance.com
Justice starts with us. And it starts now.
Invisible no more: The fight for hotel Janitors
1. The Ritz‑Carlton, Half Moon Bay
- In July 2025, the California Labor Commissioner’s Office issued over $2 million in citations against Ritz‑Carlton and three subcontractors for misclassifying 155 janitors as independent contractors.
- These workers were denied minimum wage, overtime pay, paid sick leave, workers’ compensation, and other basic labor rights.
- The contractors—Empire Unistar Management, TK Service of Virginia, and JM Spa Group—were not registered under California’s janitorial registration program, a requirement under state law.Reddit+15CalDIR+15City Attorney+15
2. Cheesecake Factory Janitors — San Diego & Orange County
- From 2014 to 2017, at least 589 janitors cleaning Cheesecake Factory restaurants were employed by subcontractors and consistently underpaid—denied overtime, proper wages, meal and rest breaks.
- In 2018, California issued a wage theft citation. A $1 million settlement followed in January 2024, with Cheesecake Factory paying $750,000, Americlean Janitorial Services $200,000, and Magic Touch Commercial Cleaning $50,000.
- Workers reported shifts starting after midnight, staying beyond eight hours without approval, and enduring unpaid overtime. One worker described working 9–10 hours nightly for just $70/day.CalMatters+5CalDIR+5HR Dive+5CalMatters+4KQED+4HR Dive+4
3. Los Angeles Grocery Janitors (Not Hotels, but similar industry risk)
- In August 2024, the LA City Attorney filed suit against janitorial contractors working for supermarket chains. The complaint covers systemic violations: failure to pay minimum and overtime wages, missing meal/rest breaks, poor records, and misclassification.
- The janitors, largely immigrant and economically vulnerable, were denied workers’ compensation, sick leave, and other protections. This highlights how chaining via subcontractors facilitates exploitation in property service industries.City Attorney
4. Long Beach Convention Center Subcontractor Case
- While not a hotel, this case shows a similar pattern of subcontracted wages in hospitality-adjacent work. In March 2025, a local union accused 1Fifty1 Inc., a subcontractor, of paying workers under the table cash wages, often below minimum wage and without overtime, violating payroll tax rules and wage-statement laws.Reddit+12Los Angeles Times+12thebusinessjournal.com+12
🔍 Why These Cases Matter for WRC A’s Advocacy
- Misclassification as “independent contractors” (rather than employees) is a central tactic used by hotel subcontractors to deny labor protections—including workers’ compensation.
- Many of these cases involved immigrant, non-English speakers or economically marginalized workers, who are less likely to report violations or demand their rights.
- These cases set enforcement precedents and demonstrate where policymakers can focus attention: janitorial registration compliance, joint employer accountability, and proactive audits.
- They reflect the systemic nature of exploitation in the janitorial industry tied to large employers (e.g. hotels, restaurants) using subcontracting chains.
📋 Summary of Key Cases
| Case / Location | Workers Affected | Misclassification Abuse | Outcome / Penalties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ritz‑Carlton, Half Moon Bay | 155 janitors | Independent contractors, no protections | >$2 million citation covering wages and penalties |
| Cheesecake Factory (San Diego, Orange) | 589 janitors | Subcontracted, unpaid overtime, no breaks | $1 million settlement; joint liability enforced |
| Grocery Janitors (Los Angeles) | ~65 workers (grocery stores) | Same pattern: no comp, rest, wages, record violations | Active civil suit seeking restitution & injunctive relief |
| Convention Center Custodial (Long Beach) | Event facility cleaners | Cash wage, under minimum wage, no documentation | Complaint filed, contract terminated, investigation ongoing |