Bids for Connection: The 86 Percent

Listen to this article

What poker can teach us about relationships

Every poker player learns to read the table — to watch the other players instead of staring at his cards. In a marriage, reading the table means noticing the smallest move your spouse makes, and it turns out that move has a name and a body of research behind it. The psychologist John Gottman, who studied couples for decades in his Seattle laboratory, called it a bid for connection: any attempt by one partner to get the other’s attention, interest, or affection. A bid is almost never grand. It is a comment — look at that bird outside — or a question, a touch on the arm, a joke, a sigh at the end of a long day. It looks like nothing. According to the research, it is everything.

When your spouse makes a bid, you have three ways to play it. You can turn toward it — look up, engage, even for a few seconds. You can turn away — ignore it, grunt without lifting your eyes from the newspaper. Or you can turn against it — answer with irritation or contempt, as if the bid itself were an offense. None of these responses takes more than a moment. All three are being dealt, one after another, hundreds of times a week, in every kitchen and living room.

Here is the finding. In a study of newlywed couples, Gottman and his colleagues found that the couples who were still married six years later had turned toward each other’s bids about eighty-six percent of the time. The couples who had divorced had turned toward only about a third of the time. Not half. A third. The difference between a marriage that lasted and one that ended was not how the couples handled the big dramatic hands — the money crises, the betrayals, the in-laws. It was how often a husband looked up from his paper when his wife mentioned a call from her sister, and asked how her sister was.

Sit with that. Most of us imagine a marriage is won or lost at the big moments, the way a poker tournament is supposed to turn on one heroic all-in. Gottman’s work suggests the opposite: a marriage is won or lost the way a stack is actually built — in small pots, constantly, by players who pay attention. The husband who looks up makes a deposit so small it barely registers; the one who grunts without looking up makes a withdrawal just as small. Neither moment feels important. Multiplied across ten thousand days, they are the marriage. The account balance is simply the sum of the tiny exchanges.

In my years of practice, couples whose marriages were ending rarely described a single catastrophic hand. They described a climate. He never listens. She doesn’t care what I think. I could say anything and it wouldn’t land. Translated out of the language of hurt, that is the arithmetic of turned-away bids — thousands of small reaches that met silence, until the reaching stopped. Nobody stops bidding all at once. They stop the way a player leaves a table: gradually, after concluding the game is not worth the ante.

The hopeful side of the research is that turning toward is a skill, and an undemanding one. It does not require a weekend seminar or a new personality. It requires noticing — treating the comment about the bird, the sigh, the hand on your arm as what it is: your spouse reaching across the table — and answering with a few seconds of attention. Eighty-six percent is not perfection. The couples who lasted missed bids too; they were tired, distracted, human. They simply caught most of them. The standard is not always. The standard is usually — and usually is within reach of anyone willing to look up.

Start with a single week of noticing. Count the bids your spouse makes in a day; you will be surprised how many there are, and how many have been passing you unobserved. Count your children’s bids too — the story begun at the dinner table, the drawing held up, the question asked from the back seat — because the same arithmetic runs at that table. Then play the week deliberately: turn toward as many as you can.

Here is the takeaway. For the next seven days, treat every small bid from your spouse — the comment, the question, the touch, the sigh — as a hand dealt directly to you, and turn toward it: look up, answer, ask the one follow-up question. You will not catch them all; nobody does, and nobody has to. The couples in Gottman’s study who were still together at six years caught about eighty-six percent. Marriages are not held by the grand gestures. They are held, bid by small bid, by players who look up.

Unknown's avatar

Author: timothymccandless

I have spent most of my professional life helping people who were being taken advantage of by systems they did not fully understand.

Leave a Reply