▶ Watch the 60-second version: Check the buyback math
The manufacturer agreed to buy back your lemon — then the number looked low. Here is how to check their math. That’s the opening of our new one-minute video, and it’s a check worth doing before you sign anything: California’s buyback formula is set by law, not by the manufacturer’s first offer. Here is the video’s short version, expanded.
Start With the Real Price
California’s formula starts with the actual price you paid or still owe, including manufacturer options and transportation charges. Not a rounded estimate, not the price minus whatever the manufacturer feels like subtracting — the real price, in full. Pull your purchase contract and check the offer line by line against it. If the starting number is already low, everything built on it will be low too.
Taxes, Fees, Towing, and Rentals Get Added Back
Then add the collateral charges: sales tax, license, registration, and other official fees, plus real costs like towing and rental cars. Those get added back to you. They are easy to overlook because they are scattered across different receipts — the tax on the contract, the registration paperwork, the tow bill from the day the car died, the rental invoices while it sat in the shop. Gather them all. A missing line here is money out of your pocket.
One Deduction Only
The manufacturer gets essentially one deduction: a mileage offset for the miles you drove before the first repair attempt for the defect. Nothing else. Not wear and tear in general, not every mile you ever drove — the miles before that first repair attempt. If the offer shows other deductions, ask what law allows them, in writing. Most low offers depend on you not knowing the deduction list is that short.
Challenge Missing Lines in Writing
If a line is missing, challenge it in writing. And a willful refusal to follow the law can add a penalty of up to two times your actual damages — which is why manufacturers take a documented challenge more seriously than a phone call. Keep your letter short, factual, and dated, list each missing item with its amount, and keep your copy with your repair records.
Get the free kit. The free California Lemon Law Kit walks through qualifying defects, repair attempts, and the buyback math step by step. It’s one of the 14 free California self-help kits in our roundup: Free Legal Help for Californians: All 14 Self-Help Kits in One Place. Watch the 60-second video first, then work the kit while your records are still together.
Watch all the Compliance Alliance Network Shorts: https://www.youtube.com/@ComplianceAllianceNetwork
Compliance Alliance Network. Educational use only. Not legal advice.