The lessons we can learn from the game of Poker
Most retirement plans are drawn as a straight line. You will spend so much a year at sixty-five, the projection assumes, and so much a year, adjusted for inflation, every year until the end. It is tidy arithmetic, and it describes almost no retirement I have ever seen. Real retirements bend. The spending of a healthy sixty-eight-year-old and the spending of the same man at eighty-eight are two different animals, and planning as if they were identical leaves money stranded in the wrong years of your own life.
A poker player would spot the error at once. No sensible player budgets his chips evenly across the night. Early in a long game the table is full, your energy is high, and the opportunities are rich; later the game narrows, the pots change character, and different things matter. The money follows the shape of the game. Retirement spending follows the shape of a life, and that shape has three distinct ages.
Planners call them the go-go years, the slow-go years, and the no-go years. In the go-go years — roughly the first decade for most of us — health and energy are strong, and the spending runs high. This is when the travel happens: the trip to Europe you promised yourselves, the long road trip, the boat, the home projects, the help for children and grandchildren who need it now rather than in some distant settlement. Retirees routinely spend more in these years than their neat projections allowed, and then feel a pang of guilt, as if they had broken the plan. They have not broken the plan. The plan was wrong.
Then come the slow-go years. Somewhere in the late seventies and eighties, the appetite for airports and itineraries fades on its own. Life becomes more local: familiar restaurants, nearby friends, the garden, the grandkids’ games. Spending drifts down — not because the money ran out, but because the desire did. Many people in these years spend noticeably less than they did at sixty-five, and accounts that were supposed to be draining quietly hold their ground.
The no-go years bend the curve back up. Discretionary spending falls further, but health care and long-term care costs can rise sharply: home aides, assisted living, the whole machinery of being cared for. Researchers who track how retirees actually spend describe the full pattern as a smile — high at the start, sagging gently through the middle, and rising again at the end on the strength of medical costs.
Why does the shape matter? Because a flat-line plan misallocates your money across your own lifetime. It rations the go-go years — the only years when you can hike the trail, walk a foreign city all day, and sleep in a strange bed without paying for it for a week — to defend against an average that never actually occurs. Your healthiest, most mobile years are a wasting asset, and money saved out of them cannot be spent back into them later. A trip forgone at sixty-eight is not stored youth. It is simply gone.
None of this licenses recklessness early on. The smile rises a second time, and the no-go years are precisely when you have the fewest options left. The care reserve is real, and a plan that spends the early years bare has traded one mistake for another. The answer is to budget the curve deliberately: size the late-life care reserve first, honestly, and then spend the go-go years without the false guilt the flat line imposed. Two pots, two purposes, each matched to the stage it serves.
That is where the poker frame earns its keep. A good player does not ask how much he may spend per hand. He asks what this stage of the game requires, and what he must still be holding when the game changes. Count your chips for the whole night, by all means. But play each stage on its own terms: spend in the go-go years while spending buys the most life, let the slow-go years ease off as they naturally will, and keep the reserve that lets the final years be met with dignity instead of fear.
Here is the takeaway. Sketch your own curve. Put rough numbers beside the three ages: what the active years should hold, what the quieter years will likely need, and what reserve the last years demand for care. If your plan assumes one flat figure forever, redraw it — and give yourself explicit, funded permission to spend more freely in the go-go years, while you are best able to enjoy it. The curve is coming either way. The only question is whether your money is shaped to meet it.