Seller Skipped the Disclosure Form in New York? You Get a $500 Credit

▶ Watch the 60-second version: Seller skipped the disclosure form? You get a $500 credit — Free Kit

In New York, a seller who skips the property disclosure form doesn’t get away with it. The buyer gets a five-hundred-dollar credit at closing instead. That is the opening of our new one-minute video, and it is the rule New York buyers most often miss: they assume a missing disclosure is just sloppy paperwork, when the law actually prices the omission. Here is the video’s short version, expanded.

No Disclosure? $500 Credit

Under Real Property Law § 462, a seller who fails to deliver the Property Condition Disclosure Statement owes the buyer a $500 credit against the purchase price at closing. The credit is automatic by law — you do not have to prove the seller hid a defect to get it. Check your closing documents: if no disclosure statement was delivered and no $500 credit appears, that is a discrepancy worth raising before the file goes cold.

Complaints Go to the DOS

Complaints about a New York agent go to the Department of State, which licenses every salesperson and broker under Article 12-A of the Real Property Law. The state holds the license, so the state is where a licensing complaint belongs — not the agent’s brokerage, not the local realtor board alone. File with the Department of State, keep copies of everything you send, and keep your own timeline of what the agent did and when.

The State Disciplines, Not Pays

The state can fine, suspend, or revoke a license for fraud, dishonest dealing, or incompetence — but it cannot order your money back. Damages take a separate claim. That split matters: a licensing complaint creates the official record and the pressure, while restitution — getting your deposit or your losses returned — runs through a demand, a negotiated settlement, or a court claim of your own. Many buyers file only one track and wonder why nothing was repaid.

Escrow Abuse Is a Top Offense

An agent who steers you, hides offers, or keeps your deposit faces more than discipline: escrow and dual-agency violations are among the most prosecuted offenses. Your deposit must sit in a proper escrow account, handled under the trust-account rules — not in the agent’s operating account and not held hostage when a deal falls apart. If your money was mishandled, say so in the complaint in those terms; it is the language the Department of State acts on fastest.

Discrimination? File with DHR Too

Discrimination by an agent opens a second door: the New York Division of Human Rights takes housing discrimination complaints, with its own investigators. Two complaints, two agencies, more leverage — a DOS licensing complaint and a DHR fair-housing complaint can run at the same time, and each builds a record the other can see.

Get the free kit. The free New York Realtor Complaints Kit walks you through the disclosure credit, the Department of State complaint, and the fair-housing route step by step — or download the PDF directly: Download the New York Realtor Complaints Kit (PDF). All 14 free New York self-help kits are here: All 14 Free New York Self-Help Kits

Compliance Alliance Network is an educational program of Workers Rights Compliance Alliance, a California nonprofit organization.

Watch all the Compliance Alliance Network Shorts: https://www.youtube.com/@ComplianceAllianceNetwork

Compliance Alliance Network. Educational use only. Not legal advice.