Denial, or Bad Faith? The California Line Insurers Can’t Cross — In 60 Seconds

▶ Watch the 60-second version: Denial, or bad faith?

Most claim denials are just disputes. Some cross a line California law names: bad faith. That is the opening of our new one-minute video, and it is the distinction that matters most after a denial — because a disagreement over what a policy covers is one fight, and an insurer that breaks the rules for handling your claim is another. If you only argue about the denial itself, you can miss the pattern that gives you real leverage. Here is the video’s short version, expanded.

The Unfair-Practices List Is Written Down

California Insurance Code section 790.03 lists unfair claims practices — things insurers may not do as a business practice. This is not a vague promise to be fair. It is a written list the Department of Insurance and the courts can measure an insurer against. When your experience matches items on that list, you are no longer just saying the decision felt wrong. You are pointing to specific conduct the Legislature has already named as unfair, and that changes how regulators, and bad-faith attorneys, will read your file.

Misquoting, Silence, and No Investigation

On that list: misrepresenting your policy terms, failing to respond to your letters promptly, and refusing to investigate your claim properly. Misquoting matters because the policy language controls — if you are told a limit or exclusion says something it does not, get the actual wording and compare it line by line. Silence matters because delay is itself a tactic; keep every letter, email, and call log with dates. And a proper investigation matters because an insurer cannot fairly deny what it never seriously looked at — if no one inspected, interviewed, or reviewed the records, say so, in writing.

Lowballs and Stalls Count Too

Also on the list: lowballing you to force a lawsuit, and stalling on a claim where liability is reasonably clear. A settlement offer far below documented loss, with no real explanation, is not just hard bargaining when its purpose is to make you sue to get what is owed. The same goes for endless requests for the same documents or months without a decision when liability is clear. One delay can be an accident. A pattern of delays, low offers, and shifting reasons is the story — and patterns are proved with a timeline, not with memory.

Document the Pattern

If you see that pattern, document every instance with dates. That record is exactly what a bad-faith attorney wants to see — and many work on contingency, so a consultation does not have to cost you upfront. Bring the denial letter, the policy, your timeline, and every response — or non-response — in order. A clean, dated record turns frustration into evidence, and it also makes your Department of Insurance complaint far stronger if you file one.

Get the free kit. The free California Insurance Denials Kit walks you through bad-faith signs, the appeal process, and Department of Insurance complaints, step by step. It’s one of the 14 free California self-help kits in our roundup: All 14 California Self-Help Kits in One Place. Watch the 60-second video first, then work the kit with your paperwork in front of you.

Watch all the Compliance Alliance Network Shorts: https://www.youtube.com/@ComplianceAllianceNetwork

Compliance Alliance Network. Educational use only. Not legal advice.

Unknown's avatar

Author: timothymccandless

I have spent most of my professional life helping people who were being taken advantage of by systems they did not fully understand.

Leave a Reply