The Hedge | Brutal Honesty Over Hype Since 2008
California is an at-will employment state — in theory. An employer can terminate an employee at any time, for any reason, without cause. In practice, California’s network of statutory protections, common law wrongful termination claims, and aggressive plaintiff’s bar has made terminating a California employee one of the most legally fraught business activities in the state. Understanding the specific risks allows employers to manage them; ignoring them invites expensive litigation.
The At-Will Doctrine and Its Exceptions
While California is at-will, the exceptions to at-will termination are so numerous that they effectively limit the doctrine significantly. You cannot terminate an employee: in retaliation for filing a workers’ compensation claim, reporting workplace safety violations, or taking protected leave (CFRA, FMLA, PDL); for reasons that constitute illegal discrimination based on any protected characteristic under FEHA; in violation of an implied contract created by an employee handbook, verbal promises, or company policies that implied job security; or in violation of public policy (firing a nurse for refusing to perform an illegal procedure, for example). Each of these exceptions is a potential wrongful termination lawsuit.
The Documentation Imperative
The single most important employer protection in a termination dispute is contemporaneous documentation. Performance issues, warnings, and improvement plans documented in real time — before any termination decision is made — are far more credible than documentation created or revised after the fact. A personnel file that shows a consistent pattern of documented performance issues, escalating warnings, and clear communication of consequences is the employer’s best defense. A personnel file that contains glowing reviews followed by a sudden termination is an invitation to wrongful termination litigation.
The Pre-Termination Checklist
Before terminating any California employee, run through: all applicable WARN Act notice requirements (for layoffs of 50+ employees at a single location within 30 days); final pay obligations (immediate for involuntary termination, including all accrued vacation); COBRA notice requirements; separation agreement considerations (if you want a release of claims, you must provide consideration, adequate time to review, and specific ADEA language for employees over 40); and a review of whether any protected characteristic, protected activity, or protected leave was a factor in the decision. The 30 minutes spent on this checklist before a termination can prevent months of litigation. The Hedge covers the complete checklist in the accompanying sidebar.
The Hedge has been cutting through financial and business noise since 2008. Brutal honesty over hype — always.
The Hedge 