The Hedge | Brutal Honesty Over Hype Since 2008
When an HOA fails to maintain common areas — allowing roofs to leak into shared ceilings, pools to become unusable, parking areas to deteriorate, or landscaping to die — affected homeowners have specific legal rights and remedies. Understanding those rights prevents the all-too-common situation where homeowners simply absorb the impact of association neglect without pursuing the accountability mechanisms Davis-Stirling provides.
The Association’s Maintenance Obligation
HOA governing documents and California law impose a duty on associations to maintain common areas in good repair. When an association fails to maintain common area components — allowing conditions to deteriorate beyond ordinary wear — it is breaching its obligation to members. For homeowners whose units are damaged by common area neglect (water intrusion through a common roof, damage from a failed common area drainage system, etc.), the association may be directly liable for the resulting damage to the member’s separate interest property.
The Maintenance Demand Process
When you identify a common area maintenance failure, the response is: written notice to the HOA board specifically identifying the defect and requesting a repair timeline. Follow up in writing if the board doesn’t respond within a reasonable time. File a code enforcement complaint if the condition creates a building or health code violation — this creates an official record independent of your communications with the board. Document the condition with photographs and video with timestamps. If the board fails to act after written notice, you have grounds for IDR and potentially a civil claim for breach of the maintenance obligation.
The Deferred Maintenance Crisis in Many Associations
Many California HOAs are facing deferred maintenance crises — backlogs of neglected repairs that accumulated during the COVID period and haven’t been addressed. Severely underfunded reserve accounts mean associations lack the money to address major maintenance items without special assessments. For homeowners in associations with significant deferred maintenance backlogs, understanding both the legal framework for demanding repairs and the reserve fund situation that underlies the neglect is essential context for navigating what is often a multi-year resolution process.
The Hedge has been cutting through financial and business noise since 2008. Brutal honesty over hype — always.
The Hedge 