The lessons we can learn from the game of Poker
Most retirement advice warns against one danger: running out of money. It is a real danger, and this book treats it seriously. But there is an opposite danger that receives a fraction of the attention, and in my experience it is every bit as common among people who saved diligently: the danger of never spending. Studies of retirees find that many — especially those with substantial savings — draw down their assets far more slowly than they safely could. Some go on accumulating wealth deep into retirement, adding to a stack they will never touch.
Some of that caution is honorable. A reserve against a long life and expensive care is prudence, not pathology, and a wish to leave something to children or causes is a legitimate purpose for money. But much of the underspending I have witnessed was neither prudence nor generosity. It was habit and fear. A lifetime of saving had made spending feel wrong — almost irresponsible — even when spending was the entire reason the money existed. The saver kept winning the accumulation game long after the game had ended, because he had never been told, or never believed, that it had.
The writer Bill Perkins made this argument forcefully in his book Die With Zero. His point was not that everyone should literally spend his last dollar on his last day; it was that money is only valuable for the experiences it allows, and experiences are rationed by age and health. A trip that would delight you at sixty-eight may be impossible at eighty-five. So money saved past the point of need, in his framing, is not really wealth at all. It is life energy — hours of your working life, spent earning — that was never converted back into living.
Every poker player knows the table version of this error. Chips have no value in themselves. They are worth only what they can do in the game: buy a pot, fund a bluff, keep you seated for the hand that matters. The player who guards his stack so carefully that he never plays it has not played well; he has not played at all. And at the end of the night, unplayed chips are just colored discs. They do not follow you home.
I know whereof I speak, because I settled the estates. In forty years of practice I closed out the affairs of careful people who had left large sums untouched while denying themselves modest pleasures for years — the trip deferred one season too many, the help at home never hired, the visit always postponed until visiting became impossible. What stayed with me was their children’s reaction. Inheriting the money, several of them wished, out loud, that their parents had spent more of it on themselves: on travel, on comfort, on ease, on joy. A balance in an account at the end of a life is not a score. Very often it is a record of experiences that did not happen.
Understand, this is not an argument for spending carelessly or dying penniless on principle. The care reserve matters. The no-go years are coming. But between recklessness and hoarding there is a wide country called enough, and the whole work of this chapter is locating it: count honestly, provide for the late years, name what the surplus is for — and then actually use the money for the purposes you named, while the purposes can still be enjoyed. An inheritance delivered at your death is a fine thing. A gift given while you are present to see it land, a journey taken while your knees still work, help hired while it can still give you good years in your own home — those are often the better plays of the same chips.
The clock is the reason, and it is unforgiving. Health is the real currency of retirement, and unlike money it cannot be saved, only spent, at a rate none of us controls. Every year you postpone the experience, you are betting that the exchange rate will hold. Sometimes it does. When it does not, the money remains and the opportunity is gone, and no balance ever printed has bought one of those back.
Here is the takeaway. If your count says you have crossed your number, pick one experience your money was saved for — the trip, the family gathering, the comfort, the help at home — and put it on the calendar this year, funded and unashamed. Then name your surplus on paper: what it is for, whose it is, and when it gets used. You spent a working life converting hours into dollars. Retirement is the season for converting them back, and the conversion window does not stay open forever.