Every Child Is a Different Player

Listen to this article

What poker can teach us about relationships

Any poker player who has spent an evening at the same table knows the central truth of the game: no two players play alike. One bets hard on weak hands because he loves the action. Another folds everything but the nuts. A third watches everybody else while barely glancing at his own cards. The cards are the same fifty-two for all of them; the players are not, and the man who treats them as if they were loses money all night. Parenting works the same way. I watched good parents — careful parents — make the poker player’s mistake: deal the same strategy to every child at the table and wonder why it only worked on one of them.

In the 1950s, two psychiatrists, Alexander Thomas and Stella Chess, began following children from infancy in what became known as the New York Longitudinal Study. What they found was something every parent of more than one child already suspects in the middle of the night: children differ from birth — not from bad parenting, but from the start — in activity level, adaptability, intensity of reaction, and general mood. Some babies were easy and adaptable, taking strangers in stride. Some were intense and hard to soothe, reacting to everything at full volume. And some were cautious, slow to warm up, needing time to watch from the edge before they joined in. These were not stages the children passed through. They were the children, as dealt.

The insight that mattered most in their work was not the labels. It was the idea of fit — how well a parent’s expectations and style matched a particular child’s temperament. A loud, firm approach that steadies one child can shut another one down entirely. A parent who demands instant obedience from a slow-to-warm child is not teaching discipline; he is asking a fish to climb a tree and then blaming the fish for the grade. The question is never whether the parenting is good in the abstract. It is whether it fits the player across from you.

Parents of more than one child learn this the hard way, usually with the second. What worked beautifully with the first — the firm limits, the clear rules, the consequence delivered and done — fails completely with the second, who needs the reason explained before the rule makes sense. One child comes home from a hard day needing an hour alone to recover; his sister comes home needing to talk it through at full speed, immediately. One child thrives on challenge and asks for the harder climb. Another needs encouragement before he will try anything new at all. Same house, same parents, same rules — different players, entirely different games.

The schoolyard game of marbles showed me the same thing. Some boys shot hard and fast, scattering everything. Some crouched and aimed for minutes before a single shot. Some watched five games before they ever knelt down to play one. Nobody coached them all the same way, because the coaching that steadied the reckless boy would have paralyzed the careful one. You read the player first. Then you decided what to say.

Reading your own children honestly requires admitting that your favorite strategy is not universal. Most of us parent the way we were parented, or the way that worked with our first child, and call it consistency. Sometimes it is consistency. Sometimes it is just one hand played over and over at a table full of different players. The parent who reads each child as an individual — who notices what soothes this one, what frightens that one, what this one needs before a new school — is doing the hardest work of parenthood. It is slower than a single rule for all — and the only approach with a chance with all of them.

The fit is the whole game: the same approach, applied to the wrong temperament, is not discipline or love — it is a misread, and misreads cost you the very child you were trying to reach.

Here is the takeaway. Take one child and write down what you know about that child’s temperament — how active, how intense, how quick or slow to warm up — and then ask whether your approach actually fits that particular child, or a different child you know better. Adjust one thing this week: more explanation for the child who needs reasons, more time alone for the child who needs to recover, more encouragement for the child who needs to believe you are on his side. You cannot re-deal your children’s temperaments. You can learn to play the players you were given, one at a time — and that is the difference between a parent who has a system and a parent who has a family.

Unknown's avatar

Author: timothymccandless

I have spent most of my professional life helping people who were being taken advantage of by systems they did not fully understand.

Leave a Reply