What poker can teach us about relationships
In 1997, the psychologist Arthur Aron and his colleagues published a study with an almost mischievous premise. Take two strangers. Sit them down together. Give them a series of questions to ask each other — questions that grow steadily more personal as they go, about their values, memories, hopes and feelings. Then measure how close the strangers feel. The answer: significantly closer than strangers who had spent the same time in small talk. The questions became famous in their own right, known ever since as the thirty-six questions — a recipe, it turned out, for manufacturing intimacy between people who had never met.
Why should a list of questions do that? Because closeness at any table is built out of matched risk. Watch a poker game: trust — if that word can be used — develops as players show a little, then a little more. The thirty-six questions run on the same escalator. The early ones are cheap to answer. The later ones cost something: a real fear, a real regret, a hope you have not said aloud. And the structure is fair, which is the genius of it. You take turns. Each player puts the same amount on the table. Nobody is interrogated; both are revealed, one matched bet at a time. Vulnerability answered with vulnerability is the oldest currency in human life, and Aron simply put it in a sequence.
Here is the part that matters most to the readers of this series. Long-married couples have taken the same questions home — couples ten, twenty, forty years in — and many report discovering things about each other they never knew. Sit with that. A man can sleep beside a woman for three decades, raise children with her, bury parents with her, and still learn, on an ordinary evening in his own kitchen, something true about her that he had never once suspected. Not because she was hiding it. Because he had never asked the question the fact was waiting behind.
I spent years taking depositions, and I can testify that the answer you get is shaped by the question you ask. Ask a man how his day was and you will learn nothing at any length. Ask what he would do if he knew he could not fail, or what his most treasured memory is, or what he wishes he had asked his father, and the room changes. Most spouses are not strangers to each other’s facts — the résumé, the relatives, the settled opinions about the neighbors. They are strangers to each other’s interiors, because the questions that open interiors stopped being asked somewhere around the second anniversary. We assume the file is complete. The file is never complete. It is only unopened.
A caution and a comfort. The caution: the questions are not an interrogation, and they will not survive being treated as one. Both players answer; both players listen; nobody scores the responses. The comfort: you do not need a laboratory, or a crisis, or even a reason. Strangers used these questions to grow close in a single sitting. A married couple brings to the table something the strangers did not have — a shared history that gives every answer resonance. An answer about a childhood fear lands differently from a woman whose childhood you have heard about for thirty years — except that, it turns out, you hadn’t. Not the important parts.
There is something quietly hopeful in Aron’s little experiment. It says intimacy is not a substance some couples were issued and others weren’t. It is a practice — a thing people do, in an order, with attention — and anything that is a practice can be resumed. The marriages that drift rarely drift because the love failed first. They drift because the questions stopped, and the two people went on changing in private, each assuming the other was standing still. Thirty-six questions will not fix a broken marriage by themselves. But they are proof, from a psychology lab, of what every good poker player knows: the other player is always more interesting than your read of him — if you keep watching.
Here is the takeaway. Find the thirty-six questions — they are widely available — and set aside one unhurried evening with your spouse. Take turns. Answer each question honestly, and let your spouse finish before you respond. You do not have to reach question thirty-six, and falling in love again is not a promised result. What couples consistently report is simpler and, to my mind, better: learning things, after all these years, that they never knew. The deck has more cards in it than you thought. Ask, and see.