The Hedge | Brutal Honesty Over Hype Since 2008
Wyoming has become the go-to state for LLC formation among entrepreneurs who understand the cost structure of different states. The reasons are specific and quantifiable. This post compares Wyoming and California LLCs across the dimensions that matter most for business owners — formation costs, annual maintenance, tax treatment, privacy protections, and asset protection strength.
Formation Costs
Wyoming: Articles of Organization filing fee: $100. No minimum share capital requirement. No publication requirement. Total day-one cost: $100 plus registered agent fees (typically $50-$150 per year).
California: Articles of Organization: $70. Initial Statement of Information: $20. First-year minimum franchise tax: $800 due within first tax year. Total first-year minimum government cost: approximately $890, with the $800 franchise tax recurring annually thereafter. California also requires a biennial Statement of Information filing ($20 every two years).
Annual Maintenance Cost
Wyoming: Annual Report: $60 minimum (for companies with assets under $250,000 in Wyoming; 0.0002% of in-state assets for larger companies). No state income tax. No franchise tax beyond the annual report fee. Total annual minimum: $60 plus registered agent.
California: Minimum franchise tax: $800, regardless of revenue or profitability. LLC fee on gross receipts: $0 (under $250,000), $900 ($250,000-$499,999), $2,500 ($500,000-$999,999), $6,000 ($1,000,000-$4,999,999), $11,790 ($5,000,000+). State income tax on owner distributions at rates up to 13.3%. Total annual minimum: $800 plus filing fees plus income tax on profits.
Privacy Protections
Wyoming: Wyoming does not require the names of LLC members or managers to be listed in public formation documents. The Articles of Organization list the registered agent only. Member and manager identity can be kept private from public records. Wyoming also has strong charging order protections — creditors of an LLC member can only obtain a charging order against distributions, not seize the membership interest itself or force liquidation of the LLC.
California: California requires the names and addresses of managers in a manager-managed LLC or all members in a member-managed LLC to be disclosed on the Statement of Information, which is a public record. Member privacy is significantly more limited than in Wyoming or Delaware.
Asset Protection
Wyoming’s charging order protection is among the strongest in the country. A creditor who obtains a judgment against an LLC member cannot seize the membership interest, vote in LLC decisions, or force dissolution of the LLC. They can only receive distributions if and when the LLC chooses to make them — and many LLC operating agreements can be structured to limit distributions during periods of active creditor threat. California’s charging order statute offers similar protections in theory, but California courts have a history of being more willing to pierce charging order protections in appropriate circumstances.
Foreign Entity Registration
If you form a Wyoming LLC but operate in California, you’ll need to register as a foreign LLC doing business in California — which requires paying California’s $800 franchise tax anyway. This is the fundamental limitation of the out-of-state formation strategy: it works for holding companies, investment vehicles, and businesses that genuinely operate outside California. It doesn’t work as a pure cost-avoidance strategy for businesses whose operations are California-based.
The Wyoming LLC is the right choice for: holding companies that own assets in multiple states, investment vehicles that can genuinely be domiciled outside California, and the structure layer above California operating entities in a multi-entity stack. The California LLC remains necessary for businesses that are genuinely operating in California and need California-specific legal relationships with California-based employees, customers, and counterparties.
The Hedge has been cutting through financial and business noise since 2008. Brutal honesty over hype — always.
The Hedge 