Listening to Understand, Not to Reply

Listen to this article

What poker can teach us about relationships

Most of us do not listen. We wait. It took me most of my life — and forty years of watching people talk past each other across my desk — to see the difference clearly. Ordinary conversation runs on a hidden trade: while you talk, I assemble what I am going to say when you stop. My advice, my defense if I sense one coming. You stop, I fire back, and we call that a conversation. In a courtroom that habit is a professional skill; advocates are paid to argue, not to absorb. In a family, it is a slow disaster, because the person talking never finishes feeling heard, and eventually — usually quietly — stops talking.

You see the pattern everywhere once you notice it. A wife begins describing a frustrating day, and before two sentences are out her husband has interrupted with a solution. A teenager starts explaining a conflict with a friend, and her father is halfway into a lecture before she has named it. A son calls home about trouble at a job, and within a minute his mother is reassuring, correcting, planning. Every one of those responses may be well meant; not one of them is listening. The speaker came with something to lay down; what got picked up instead was the listener’s agenda. Then we wonder why the teenager’s door closes. People do not stop having things to say. They stop saying them to people who never actually receive them.

Counselors teach a practice for this, humbler than most of us expect: reflective listening, or active listening. The listener’s job is not to solve, judge, defend or advise. It is to understand — and then to prove it by playing back what he heard and checking whether he got it right. It sounds like you felt embarrassed when your boss criticized you in front of everyone. Is that right? It sounds too small to matter. It matters enormously, because it is nearly the only sentence in an ordinary day that tells the other person: I was following your hand, not playing mine.

Notice what the practice demands. You have to set down your own cards while someone else is holding theirs. You have to let a sentence finish — all the way, including the part at the end that changes its meaning. You have to hear an emotion you may not like — anger at you, sometimes, or fear you caused — without immediately filing your objection. And then, instead of answering it, you hand it back for verification, giving the speaker the right to correct the record. For people trained to win arguments, this is close to unnatural. It is also the closest thing I know to a skill that changes a marriage by itself: most people do not want their problems solved by the person across the table. They want them witnessed.

A poker table teaches the shape of it. The good listener is like the player still watching a hand he folded two streets ago — not planning his next move, just reading, because the information arriving now decides every later hand. When you summarize and check, two things happen at once: misunderstandings get caught while they are still cheap — no, I wasn’t angry at you, I was scared about the money — and the speaker feels respected in a way no advice can deliver. Advice says, I have analyzed your situation. Reflecting says, I heard you. The first builds an argument. The second builds the account your marriage draws on in the bad hands.

For years, my listening meant loading my reply like a spring. My wife would be three sentences into a worry and I was already cross-examining it — is this fact right, is that fair, what is my answer. She was not asking for an advocate. She was asking for a witness. The day I learned to say tell me more and actually wait, several long-running arguments lost their fuel — most of what sounded like disagreement had only been a request to be heard out.

Nobody feels understood by a person who is visibly reloading. Understanding is not what happens in your head while someone talks; it is what the other person experiences when you show them what you heard.

Here is the takeaway. The next time someone you love starts telling you something that matters, put down your reply. Listen to the end. Then offer one sentence beginning with it sounds like, and finish with is that right? If you got it wrong, let them correct you; that correction is the conversation working, not failing. Most talks in your house need your attention more than your answers. Read your people the way a good player reads a table — patiently, and long enough to learn what they are holding.

Unknown's avatar

Author: timothymccandless

I have spent most of my professional life helping people who were being taken advantage of by systems they did not fully understand.

Leave a Reply