▶ Watch the 60-second version: Hawaii’s Lemon Law: Three Strikes and They Buy It Back — Free Kit
Hawaii’s Lemon Law presumption needs only three strikes: the same defect examined or repaired at least three times and still not fixed — or one attempt at a defect likely to cause death or serious injury — or thirty or more business days in the shop. That is the opening of our new one-minute video, and three — not four — is the number that matters in Hawaii. Here is the video’s framework, expanded with the sections that control it.
Three Tries — Not Four
Under HRS § 481I-3(d), the presumption arises in three ways. First, the same nonconformity has been subject to examination or repair at least three times and continues to exist. Second, a single attempt is enough when the defect is likely to cause death or serious bodily injury. Third, the vehicle has been out of service for thirty or more business days for warranty repairs. Many owners wait for a fourth failure because they are thinking of another state’s law. In Hawaii, waiting can waste time inside a short rights period.
The Written Notice Trap
The trap the video stresses: the presumption arises only if you first gave the manufacturer written notice of the need for repair. Dealer visits alone do not count — the letter to the manufacturer is what arms your claim. Keep a copy, keep proof of mailing, and keep every repair order with dates in and out. Without that written notice, a strong repair history can still stumble at the presumption step.
Full Price Back, Including the Tax
Win, and under § 481I-3(b) the manufacturer must repurchase or replace: a refund of the full contract price including collateral charges and the general excise tax, plus incidental costs like towing — minus a use offset of one percent of the price per thousand miles. That offset is the only routine deduction built into the formula, which is why documenting mileage at delivery and at each repair matters.
Motorcycles Are Covered — and the Clock Is Short
Motorcycles are covered in Hawaii — mopeds and motor scooters are not. The rights period is the earliest of the warranty expiring, two years after delivery, or twenty-four thousand miles, under § 481I-2. The deadline is short: suit must be filed within one year after the rights period expires, under § 481I-3(j). Hawaii also runs a state arbitration program, SCAP, that can decide the claim first — the kit walks through both doors, so you can calendar the suit deadline even while arbitration is pending.
Get the free kit. The free Hawaii Lemon Law Kit walks you through the presumption, the written notice, the refund math, SCAP, and the filing deadline step by step. For the whole library, see all 14 free Hawaii self-help kits.
Watch all the Compliance Alliance Network Shorts: https://www.youtube.com/@ComplianceAllianceNetwork
Compliance Alliance Network. Educational use only. Not legal advice.