Reading the Cycle: The Signals of the Late Hand

Listen to this article

Business is like the game of Poker

A poker game has an hour to it, and so does every market. Early in the night the bets are careful, the players are fresh, and nobody is chasing losses. Late in the night the pots grow wild: tired players loosen, and money guarded at eight o’clock gets pushed into the middle at midnight on hands that would have been folded hours earlier. The cards did not change. The hour did. The most expensive misreading in business is the same one made with a balance sheet instead of a chip stack: failing to see where in the cycle you are standing.

Real estate taught me this in the hardest classroom available, because it is the market I have worked in all my life. In the years before the housing crash that began in 2007, the signals were on the table for anyone willing to look at them instead of the rising prices. Loans were being approved with little documentation of income and little or no money down. Buyers who never intended to live in a house were purchasing two or three at a time, expecting to flip them within months. Builders were grading subdivisions in outlying country far from any employment center, certain the demand would never slow. And in market after market, prices had pulled far away from the local incomes that ultimately have to carry them. None of that told you the month the music would stop. All of it told you what kind of hand the table was playing.

The late hand has a signature, and it repeats itself in industry after industry. Credit becomes unusually easy: money flows to people and projects that would not have qualified a few years before. Newcomers flood in — the waiter, the schoolteacher, the retired couple are suddenly in the game, because lately the game has made everyone look brilliant. Prices detach from the earnings and incomes underneath them, and when someone points at the gap, commentators explain why the old rules no longer apply. In the late hand, caution itself is mocked as old-fashioned, a failure of imagination. The man who keeps his reserves is pitied as someone who does not understand the new world — right up until the old one comes back.

The early hand carries the opposite signature, and it is worth memorizing, because that is where fortunes are quietly started. Credit is tight and bankers are gloomy. Experienced players have retreated to the rail, protecting what is left of their stacks. Prices sit below what the underlying assets can genuinely earn — the rents, the profits, the real cash — because nobody wants to own anything. The prevailing mood is despair, and despair, like euphoria, is information about the table rather than a fact about the assets. It was in that weather, in 2008, that Warren Buffett chose to be greedy while others were fearful — at prices no cheerful market would have offered him.

Notice what reading the cycle does not require. It does not require predicting the future, naming the top, or calling the bottom. Nobody at any table does those things reliably, and the man who claims he can is selling something. It requires a humbler skill: noticing the mood of the room and asking one question with real honesty. Are the bets being made around me justified by the cards — the incomes, the earnings, the actual demand — or only by the belief that the cards will keep getting better? When the honest answer is the belief, you are in the late hand whatever the calendar says, and the correct play is to tighten up, shorten your commitments, and hold chips in reserve for the morning after.

I have sat in both hours of that game. I have bought in the despair, when sellers were grateful a buyer existed, and done well. And I have watched good men — smart men, careful men — build fine projects in the late hand on land bought at late-hand prices, and lose everything when the cycle turned. Not because the projects were bad. Because the hour was wrong, and no craftsmanship repeals the hour.

Here is the takeaway. Once a quarter, read your own market the way you would read a table at midnight. Is credit loosening or tightening? Are inexperienced newcomers flooding in or quietly leaving? Do prices still answer to the earnings and incomes beneath them? Is caution being respected or ridiculed? Write the answers down. You are not trying to forecast the turn — you are deciding how much of your stack belongs in the middle of the table at this particular hour, and that decision, made honestly, is worth more than any prediction.

Unknown's avatar

Author: timothymccandless

I have spent most of my professional life helping people who were being taken advantage of by systems they did not fully understand.

Leave a Reply