Where Enough Goes Further

Listen to this article

The lessons we can learn from the game of Poker

Every number in this chapter so far has carried a hidden assumption: that you will live where you live now. Change the assumption and the number itself changes — sometimes dramatically. Enough is not a fixed figure stamped on your forehead. It is a relationship between what you have and what your life costs, and the cost side of that ledger is set largely by geography. The same stack of chips plays very differently at a different table.

Consider the arithmetic that thousands of retirees have already run. A couple sells a home in a high-cost coastal market — the kind of house that appreciated for forty years while they were busy living in it — and buys a comparable home somewhere less expensive for a fraction of the price. The difference does not vanish; it moves into their investments, where it can throw off income for the rest of their lives. A house that was consuming taxes, insurance, and maintenance becomes, in the move, several hundred thousand dollars of additional security. Nothing about their savings habits changed. Their address did.

Then there are the taxes, which vary more than most people realize until they start comparing. States treat retirement income very differently: some tax Social Security benefits, pensions, and withdrawals from retirement accounts, and some largely leave them alone. Property taxes on the same house can differ by thousands of dollars a year depending on the state and county it sits in. Stack those differences across a twenty- or twenty-five-year retirement and geography alone — no extra saving, no extra risk, no market luck — can redraw your number by six figures. A plan that comes up short in one zip code may clear the finish line comfortably in another.

I came to this honestly, as a developer. My whole working life was an education in the fact that dirt is not priced by what it is but by where it sits — the same acre, the same floor plan, worth wildly different sums forty miles apart. Retirees are allowed to use that lesson in reverse. During the working years, your location is mostly chosen for you by your job. In the late game, for the first time since you were young, the map opens up. The question stops being “can we afford to retire?” and becomes “where does what we have buy the life we actually want?”

Enough is partly a place: the same savings that leave you short in one town can leave you free in another.

Now the honest cautions, because a cheaper table is not automatically a better game. A move is a fold of your current life, and some of what you fold cannot be rebought at any price: the friends of thirty years, the doctors who know your history, the grandchildren an hour away instead of a plane ride. Retirees who chase cost alone sometimes win the arithmetic and lose the life. The wise move weighs the full hand — cost, yes, but also climate, medical care, community, and distance from the people who will matter most in the no-go years, when a cheap house far from everyone is the most expensive one you own.

There is also a middle path worth naming. You do not have to cross the country to change your number. Moving within your own region — out of the high-tax county, down from the expensive suburb to the smaller town twenty minutes away where your friends still visit — can capture much of the savings with far less of the uprooting. And whatever the distance, test before you commit: rent in the new place for a season before you sell, live there as a resident rather than a tourist, visit the hospital, and price the groceries. A spreadsheet can tell you what a town costs. Only a season tells you what it is like.

None of this obliges anyone to move. If your number clears where you stand, geography is simply one more chip you may never need to play. But if the count has been telling you “not quite,” do not assume the only answers are working longer or spending less. Sometimes the finish line is not out of reach. It is just located somewhere else.

Here is the takeaway. Run your number twice: once for the life where you live now, and once for a place you would genuinely consider — a smaller town, a lower-tax state, the community nearer your children. Compare them honestly, costs and people both. Knowing where your enough goes furthest costs you nothing but an evening of arithmetic, and it may hand you options you did not know you were holding.

Unknown's avatar

Author: timothymccandless

I have spent most of my professional life helping people who were being taken advantage of by systems they did not fully understand.

Leave a Reply