▶ Watch the 60-second version: Illinois Insurers Face a $60,000 Bad-Faith Penalty — § 155
If an Illinois insurer’s denial or delay is vexatious and unreasonable, section 155 lets the court add your attorney’s fees plus a penalty — capped at the smallest of sixty percent of your recovery, sixty thousand dollars, or the amount by which your recovery beats their last offer. That is the opening of our new one-minute video, and it is the leverage most Illinois policyholders never learn about until it is too late. Here is the video’s short version, expanded.
Bad Faith Costs Them — Up to $60,000
Under 215 ILCS 5/155, a vexatious and unreasonable denial or delay is not free for the insurer. A court can add attorney’s fees plus a penalty, capped at the smallest of three figures: 60% of your recovery, $60,000, or the excess of your recovery over the insurer’s last offer before suit. That cap is why documenting the insurer’s last offer, and the gap between that offer and what you actually recover, matters from the start.
§ 155 Is the Only Door
Section 155 is a remedy inside a suit on the policy, not a standalone claim — and under Cramer v. Insurance Exchange Agency (1996), it is the only extracontractual route. Illinois has no separate first-party bad-faith tort. That means you do not file a free-standing “bad faith” lawsuit; you sue on the policy and ask for the section 155 fees and penalty inside that case.
15 Days to Respond, 30 to Explain
Claims handling has clocks. Under 50 Ill. Adm. Code 919.40 and 919.50, the insurer must respond to your communications within fifteen working days, and give a written explanation of a denial or low offer within thirty days after its investigation wraps up. Put your communications in writing, keep dates, and hold the insurer to those timelines — a missed clock helps show the delay was unreasonable.
Health Claims: 30 Days Plus 9%
Health claims have their own rule: pay within thirty days of due proof of loss, or owe nine percent annual interest on the late payment, under 215 ILCS 5/368a(c). Interest accrues on late health payments, so a slow payment is not cost-free either.
External Review Binds Them
Health plan denial? External review by an independent organization is binding on the carrier under 215 ILCS 180: request it within four months. Standard decisions come within forty-five days; urgent ones within seventy-two hours. Because the decision binds the carrier, do not let the four-month window pass while you are still arguing internally.
Get the free kit. The free Illinois Insurance Denials Kit (https://compliancealliancenetwork.com/illinois/insurance-denials/) walks you through section 155, the Cramer rule, the claims timelines, health-claim interest, and external review step by step. And if you want the whole library, all 14 free Illinois self-help kits are gathered in one place: All 14 Free Illinois Self-Help Kits (https://compliancealliancenetwork.com/illinois/). Start with the 60-second video (https://www.youtube.com/shorts/97ApczJtL5I), then work the kit while your deadlines are still open.
Watch all the Compliance Alliance Network Shorts: https://www.youtube.com/@ComplianceAllianceNetwork
Compliance Alliance Network. Educational use only. Not legal advice.